Would anyone like to critique my new logo?

[Stepehen]

I think I would lose the dirt stuff at the bottom and change the background to create more contrast, losing the dirt will make it simpler and look better at a smaller size.

 

[KleptoKat]

Looks great, but it may look a bit nicer with a different background colour, fix up those raindrops a little more to make them less static, and the sand at the bottom looks a bit too brushed on.

 

[lindenalexander]

Completely agree with what everybody else wrote, it's really really nice BUT the background and the water drops need a change =) But good work!

 

[thom]

this is illustration not logo

 

[dubyaogee]

I like it. Keep in mind that if this needs to be produced on promotional products, it could be an issue. you really need a non-gradient version (vector) for it to be produced on different substrates like, cups, mugs, tshirts, etc. Conceptually, it is very nice.

 

[chrishirst]

you really need a non-gradient version (vector)

???

gradients and vectors are not mutually exclusive.

 

[d a v e]

but they (gradients) dont work very well in one colour e.g. black one a poor quality medium like (some) cardboard with (some) - i think that's what they mean.